SOTOMAYOR AND THE DANGER OF RACIAL POLITICS IDENTITIES
I have been warning for years about the trap, the dead end street, the danger of identities based on racial politics. Recently, a political party that was supposed to be the example of multiculturalism and racial/ethnic and gender harmony was visibly divided precisely along those lines.
We warned about this as far back as 1988 when we saw the Democratic Party go from being the party of immigrants and the middle and working classes to the party of “politically correct” causes. Such superficial coalitions of interest pressure groups led the Democratic Party to become the party of appearances during the past presidential elections.
From the very beginning of his candidacy, then Sen. Obama’s race, ethnicity, religion and culture were placed under question. “Is Sen. Obama Black enough?”, “Is Sen. Obama ‘the magic Negro’ (LA Times)?” These were questions not posed by “old, balding, white male” Republicans, conservatives or “the vast right-wing conspiracy”. No, they came from Democrats and the racial identity politics in the Democratic Party.
Recently the headlines read, “A happy day for all Hispanics”. Why were all of us supposed to be happy? Because a Hispanic female, “a Latina”, has been nominated by President Obama to the Supreme Court? So happy days are here again!
Yes, let us establish in no uncertain terms that we are proud of the personal accomplishments of Judge Sotomayor, a fellow “Puerto Rican”. Her story and that of her parents is not unlike that of many of us. We can relate.
We are also proud of Judge José Cabranes.
So let’s move to “brass tacks”. Is her personal story alone, so crammed down our throats by the main stream media, qualification enough for a seat at the Supreme Court? Are we “all Hispanics” alike, think alike and therefore supposed to jump and say “how high” when a political party says “jump” over their definition of what constitutes a real “Hispanic”?
I recall two recent Hispanics with similar life stories and accomplishments who did not receive equal support among politically assigned Hispanics. In fact, one of them was being considered as a potential Supreme Court candidate, way before Sotomayor. In fact, he was attacked as unqualified for the post, not because of academic and professional qualifications, but precisely for being “Latino” and an immigrant.
Remember Miguel Estrada? Addressing Democratic Party affiliated organizations, Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL) said he was especially singled out “as especially dangerous, because he has a minimal paper trail, he is Latino, and the White House seems to be grooming him for a Supreme Court appointment. They want to hold Estrada off as long as possible." “He is Latino” are code words for possibly Catholic, possibly a danger to unquestionable judicial dogmas.
The question around President Obama’s candidacy was whether or not then Sen. Obama could play ball with the old guard of the Civil Rights/welfare politics establishment of the Democratic Party with its history of racial politics.
Now we have a “Latina” twisting in her chair, attempting an existential political balancing act that should have nothing to do with whether or not she is qualified and has the judicial temperament for a place in the highest court in the country.
Now it is out there for all to see. The danger is having our racial or ethnic identities and heritage made equal to party membership or ideological identity. If Sotomayor represents true diversity there is much too celebrate. If it is another reaffirmation that ethnic identity equals an ethnic identity in line with an ideological program or agenda, then I'm not so sure that's the diversity we need.
Sotomayor’ statement, "I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion [as a judge] than a white male who hasn't lived that life" (NY Times May 15), should be at the very least cause for pause. There are racial connotations in it indeed. Is it racist? Does that make her a racist?
Sotomayor’s statements, as troubling as they are in their own standing, do not trouble me as much as why they were made: the racial identity politics imposed on us by a white liberal academic establishment for decades now and its hermeneutics of gender/race.
What Sotomayor represents for the problem of race lies with the issue of Hispanics accepting the narrative that Hispanics are a race, and a victim one at that. They have accepted the definition of “White” as Anglo-Saxon only, and of Hispanic/Latino as other than. In the case of Puerto Rican this is particularly misleading.
If you look at the ruling elite in Puerto Rico you will see what I mean. Overwhelmingly they are all white/Caucasian descendants of white/Caucasian Europeans, Spaniards, French, Italians, Germans and Irish. But the culture, as well as most of the population, is the result of historical “mestizo” forging of African, indigenous and Europeans populations into a national identity. What Puerto Ricans are proud of is not their “race”, but of the fact of how those races have forged a distinct culture. There is no “white” or “black” food, music, or dance in Puerto Rico; there is a Puerto Rican culture. And as unified as they are by a culture Puerto Ricans are equally divided by politics.
There are other statements made by Judge Sotomayor that should be examined to judge her judicial temperament, philosophy and world-view. She should be judged on those statements. But she should not be judged based on a definition of what white liberals determine of what is a real Hispanic or Latina. The same should have taken place when judging Miguel Estrada and Alberto Gonzalez. They also had compelling personal stories. Yet both were destroyed out of higher public service for not having the correct identity.
During his campaign President Obama, said that the generation of the 60s is burnt out and only offers more of the same, more of the stale and divisive politics. Yet here we are. The political struggle for the Hispanic vote will continue. The measure for political parties aspiring to their respect and consideration will be whether that respect and consideration will be mutual.
Let what is happening in the Sotomayor case stand as a warning about what happens to a minority group when racial/ethnic identity becomes equal to party or ideological identity. And what can happen when solutions to our many common problems are not measured by what their own success can demonstrate but by the identity of who proposes them. Our equal protection and common life under the Constitution should be based on “what” we are as a nation, not on “who” we are as separate identities. For anyone aspiring to the Supreme Court that is the measure.
31 Comments:
chocolate
巧克力
嗓音美容
聲帶結節
聲帶息肉
聲音萎縮
提供最佳的十大生活資訊與分享:
你知道哪裡有好吃的蛋糕嗎!
你知道白蟻如何防治嬤!
汽車隔熱紙一定是越貴越好嬤!
哪一種棧板是具有環保!
台中哪一家整形醫師縫雙眼皮最讓妳滿意!
關鍵字的搜尋行銷要領
如果要高雄旅遊,讓我告訴你高雄縣旅遊觀光景點
會計事務所到底是做哪些事!
長期照顧老人看護要如何選擇
哪裡可以選到價廉物美的服飾批發!
Thank you to all who have left comments. Unfortunately, I have not been able to read them. For some reason they are all in computer symbols. I have not idea how to fix this. If anybody knows please send suggestions to amoros.research@gmail.com. Thanks.
高雄旅遊 高雄旅遊
高雄一日遊 高雄一日遊
墾丁旅遊 墾丁旅遊
墾丁一日遊 墾丁一日遊
墾丁旅遊網 墾丁旅遊網
高雄縣旅遊 高雄縣旅遊
阿里山旅遊 阿里山旅遊
你想要到高雄/墾丁旅遊包車或是租車旅遊嗎!!!
你想了解高雄/墾丁旅遊的景點與住宿資訊嗎!!!
歡迎你到我的網站參觀與指教喔^^
潘朵拉日韓服飾購物商城
潘朵拉日韓服飾購物商城專業的服裝批發網站提供您優質的服飾批發、日本服飾批發、日系服飾批發、精品服飾批發、精品服飾、進口服飾批發、流行服飾、韓國服飾、日韓服飾批發、雜誌款服飾批發、女裝服飾批發、時尚服飾批發、少女服飾批發、衣服批發等,均為日韓流行時尚雜誌款式的女裝批發,向海內外客戶提供款式最新,品質最好,價格最優的日韓服裝、日韓流行服裝批發。
十年大陸越南新娘介紹經驗,合法的婚姻介紹機構,嚴肅,專業的婚姻介紹網站,擁有台灣多家外籍新娘婚姻協會人員合作,本網站是由大陸當地台灣媒人所設立,位於廣西省,臨近越南河內,娶外籍新娘通過本站直接到異國娶親,省掉台灣外籍新娘婚姻仲介中間環節,可以節省費用,全台各地都有我們所服務過的客人,如有需要可提供電話詢問,我們的口碑經的起檢驗,也可為你推薦台灣合法信譽好的婚姻協會人員為你服務,希望通過我們讓你以最經濟實惠的方式找到理想的伴侶,能夠為有緣人牽線搭橋,異國姻緣一線牽,歡迎以婚姻為目的,具備嚴肅婚姻心態,有責任感,有心想娶外籍新娘的台灣單身男士與我們聯繫,我們將誠心為您服務!
外籍新娘
大陸新娘
越南新娘
東北新娘
廣西新娘
吉林新娘
福建新娘
中國新娘>>>參考網站
外籍新娘 外籍新娘
大陸新娘 大陸新娘
越南新娘 越南新娘
東北新娘 東北新娘
廣西新娘 廣西新娘
吉林新娘 吉林新娘
福建新娘 福建新娘
中國新娘 中國新娘
八八水災重創南台灣,歡迎到我的網站回憶南台灣的水山風光~~~
台南旅遊 台南旅遊
台南一日遊 台南一日遊
墾丁包車 墾丁包車
高雄租車 高雄租車
日月潭旅遊 日月潭旅遊
日月潭包車 日月潭包車
高雄一日遊 高雄一日遊
墾丁旅遊 墾丁旅遊
墾丁一日遊 墾丁一日遊
墾丁旅遊網 墾丁旅遊網
高雄縣旅遊 高雄縣旅遊
阿里山旅遊 阿里山旅遊
網路行銷
什麼是網路行銷?網路行銷的最簡單定義就是讓貴公司的網站不停的曝光!在所有的行銷廣告中,只有網路行銷是24小時的行銷方式,也就是說您的客戶可以任由網路資訊的搜尋,當貴公司是屬於假日休息狀態時,亦能透過網路行銷的方式,清楚的瀏覽到網站內所呈現的資訊與服務,來滿足客戶的需求與行銷的目的。
在全球中有90%以上的國際廠商已經在使用搜尋引擎進行網路行銷方式,貴公司網站登錄搜尋引擎了嗎?貴公司網站一定要在全球最大的搜尋引擎Google及台灣最大的搜尋引擎Yahoo,因為只有seo排名Top10的網站才能享有大量曝光率,登錄搜尋引擎才能發揮最大的效果,試想如果您的網站排名在100名以外,會有多少採購廠商能找到貴公司網站呢?首頁科技網路行銷seo協助貴公司網站進入Google或Yahoo排名首頁,讓貴公司有效的提昇曝光率,大量的訂單及詢價單讓您不亦樂乎,網路行銷再也不是一件困難的事了!
祥億房屋
本公司成立於民國80年5月,這十七年來,祥億房屋專精於法院拍賣房地產代標及資訊收集與顧問諮詢,對這個產業的深耕與努力,使祥億在法拍標購之領域上均能呈現穩定及持續的成長亦累積對法拍實務的經驗實非一般公司所能比擬,祥億房屋於1997年7月早已建立了龐大的不動產之資料庫,能夠提供客戶更健全、更完整、更確實的顧問服務,並於1997年完成企業內部IT整體架構,全面提供高效率及穩定的系統架構,並成立『祥億房屋』網站;由於網際網路的蓬勃發展,祥億房屋為因應更多的消費者的需求,將於2008年大規模的改版,並將網站名稱改為『祥億房屋法拍網』,以藉由多元化的通路及更完整資料庫架構,包含實物照片、學區環境、週邊設備、地圖位置…等,跨越時間、地域的限制,延伸祥億房屋的品牌及其增加服務品質及效率。
當您想洽詢法拍屋或>房屋仲介相關資訊時,請進入 "用心服務、永續經營" 的祥億房屋仲介法拍網。房屋仲介的專業團隊,祥億房屋仲介在法拍屋代標方面,自法拍屋、一般房屋仲介買賣物件提供調查、標價提供、屋款處理、專業點交…等均由具有“自信”專業人員一貫作業全程處理,相信能給予客戶最大之保障,在房屋仲介方面具有實力雄厚之組織團體,為您分析市場價格,大量之廣告、熱忱之服務,讓買賣均能儘速達成交易保障,早日讓您成為投資或自住不動產之最佳受業人。
法拍屋、法拍>>>參考網站
Taiwan's flooding caused by the disaster, let us love to play together to help those in need of help, and now you need to do is click on any one keyword for each link will be sponsored by the NT one dollar, let us work together to create world peace ~ thank you!
台灣這次受到洪水侵襲造成巨大災難,讓我們發揮愛心一起幫助這些需要幫助的人,現在你只要每點擊任何一個關鍵字連結,將會得到新台幣一元的贊助,讓我們一起共同創造世界和平~感謝您!
旅遊 法拍屋 服飾
婦產科 大陸外籍新娘 新娘
納豆保健食品 瑜珈教室
彌月蛋糕 汽車旅館MOTEL 台中住宿
清潔公司 法拍屋 看護
隔熱紙 seo 網路行銷
整形外科 看護 整形
室內設計 系統傢俱 網頁設計
柴犬 哈士奇 網頁設計
防爆工具 瑜珈 機票
Love Without Borders, in response to Taiwan's 88 flood, please go to my site ~ Thank you for blessing the whole world!
雲林山區立委補選國民黨提名參選人張艮輝,98/8/23於斗南成立服務處。當天誠心為88災民祈福,祈願蒼天福澤災民,能快速重建家園。
雲林立委候選人張艮輝於會場上表達一貫堅持的參選理念,「一份理想、2 個希望、 3大改變」,並藉盛會為台灣祈福,場上的台灣加油地圖由地方代表等數十人點燃230支蠟燭,代表為台灣加油並點亮台灣因受88水災所面臨的黑暗期,在點燃蠟燭的同時,張艮輝也宣讀為台灣祈福文表示願為台灣這塊土地承受所有苦難。
雲林、國民黨、雲林立委、張艮輝>>>參考網站
I wish you health and happiness every day!
Ich wünsche Ihnen Glück und Gesundheit jeden Tag!
Je vous souhaite santé et bonheur chaque jour!
整形
婦產科
張艮輝
法拍屋
瑜珈
服飾
隔熱紙
清潔
雲林
Recommend some of Taiwan's high-quality sites so that you do reference and to share ~ and we wish everyone peace and happiness!
Insulation paper:隔熱紙,health foods:保健食品,Baby Cakes:彌月蛋糕
Kaohsiung County Tourism:高雄縣旅遊,>Kaohsiung yoga:高雄瑜珈,Shiba Inu:柴犬
Kenting Tourism:墾丁旅遊,cleaning companies清潔公司,cheese cake:乳酪蛋糕
Clothing wholesale:服飾批發,Vietnamese brides:越南新娘,brides from mainland China:大陸新娘
Shaping:整形,MOTEL:MOTEL,Japanese clothing:日系服飾
Jelly silicone:果凍矽膠,brides from mainland China:外籍新娘,Kaohsiung Tourism:高雄旅遊
Cake:蛋糕,yoga classes:瑜珈教室,Torque Wrench:扭力板手
Internet marketing:網路行銷,website ranking:網站排名,seo:seo
Confidence, perseverance, courage, all three in place, then the world is not impossible to do things.
http://www.104woo.com.tw
www.104woo.com.tw/index.htm
www.kinghouse.cc
www.kinghouse.cc/house.php
On the ground planted vegetables, it is unlikely that long grass; the hearts of the good, it is unlikely that health evil.
www.gayoyoga.com.tw
www.gayoyoga.com.tw/teacher.html
www.gayoyoga.com.tw/time.html
www.sunny-yoga.net
www.sunny-yoga.net/news/news001.php?userid=6&page=1
www.sunny-yoga.net/aboutus/aboutus.php
Sur le terrain planté de légumes, il est peu probable que l'herbe longue, le cœur du bien, il est peu probable que le mal de la santé.
Auf dem Boden gepflanzt Gemüse, ist es unwahrscheinlich, dass die hohen Gras, die Herzen der gut ist, ist es unwahrscheinlich, dass die Gesundheit das Böse.
............♥
...........****
..........******
.........********
........**********
......*************
.....*****HAPPY***
....*****************
...*******************
..*********************
...........****
...........****
...........****
Day, doing nothing is the life of the consumers; positive pay, is the creator of life. Nothing to do, that is, had an empty life; If people continue to pay the interest, that is, good life.
www.hoard.com.tw
www.hoard.com.tw/default.php
www.hoard.com.tw/product_08.html
www.hoard.com.tw/about_us2.html
www.hoard.com.tw/chocolate.htm
www.ta89.com
www.ta89.com/about
www.ta89.com/index.htm
www.ta-520.com
Do the right thing is smart to do should not do is ignorance.
SEO
網路行銷
SEO
網路行銷
1.你了解關鍵字廣告的陷阱與秘密???
2.你了解SEO技巧???
3.你了解網路行銷的方式與種類???
4.你了解關鍵字行銷後的商機!!!
5.你了解SEO作業與流程!!!
6.你認為網路行銷多少才合理???
7.你了解網站排名的注意事項!!!
新彩整形外科診所
整形、整形外科、隆乳、內視鏡隆乳、豐胸、果凍矽膠、雙眼皮、割雙眼皮、縫雙眼皮、開眼頭、眼袋、隆鼻、韓式隆鼻、抽脂、削骨、狐臭、>>>參考網站
你想選擇一位大陸新娘 外籍新娘的話,請進入我的網站也許就是你一生中最好的選擇。
納豆 保健食品要如何選擇呢?
選擇現代生活中最好的運動就是瑜珈,要選擇瑜珈就要先了解瑜珈教室設備、師資及瑜珈教學喔!
高雄瑜珈中的簡善琳瑜珈教室是南部地區最完善的瑜珈教室耶^^
MOTEL就是汽車旅館,它是提供情人溫馨休息住宿的好地方,到台中住宿時別忘了到台中汽車旅館看看喔!!!
台中乳酪蛋糕中禾雅堂乳酪蛋糕提供讓您難忘的蛋糕口味,除了chocolate蛋糕之外還有中秋禮盒多種樣式。
選購服飾潘朵拉日韓服飾有日系服飾、服飾批發、流行服飾及韓國服飾。
外籍新娘 大陸新娘 越南新娘這些都是一生一世最專業的服務與選擇。
您在尋找墾丁旅遊網資訊嗎?畯富包車旅遊提供阿里山旅遊 高雄縣旅遊 高雄租車 高雄計程車 高雄一日遊 機場接送等專業服務,高雄旅遊 墾丁旅遊超值網站。
僑泰裝潢廚具網是全台最大的居家生活廚具網站有廚具 廚具工廠 系統傢俱 傢俱 裝潢 抽油煙機以及系統櫃、歐化廚具 室內設計作品與免費室內設計喔!
網路行銷是網站曝光的首要指標,如何能讓網站排名於首頁是需要靠SEO技術與專業,當然關鍵字的選擇就格外重要了,這是決定瀏覽者在搜尋行銷中唯一的方向。網路行銷seo
你了解整形有哪些手術?整形外科一定要具有專科證照醫師才是基本要素。隆乳 果凍矽膠是目前市面上最好的材質!
汽車隔熱紙 大樓隔熱紙有何差異?隔熱紙不是係數越高效果就會越佳喔!
隆乳
清潔公司
高雄縣旅遊
廚具
柴犬
巧克力
墾丁旅遊
台中汽車旅館
哈士奇
系統傢俱
整形
I am from Taiwan! Si vous voulez visiter Taiwan, bienvenue sur mon site et des visites Zhijiao, je vais proposer divers types de visites guidées et visites guidées ...
I am from Taiwan! If you want to visit Taiwan, welcome to my site visits and Zhijiao, I will provide various guided tours and guided tours .
Ich komme aus Taiwan! Wenn Sie nach Taiwan besuchen möchten, herzlich willkommen auf meiner Besuche vor Ort und Zhijiao, werde ich verschiedene geführte Touren bieten und Führungen ...
高雄旅遊
墾丁旅遊
阿里山旅遊
日月潭旅遊
清境旅遊
包車旅遊
高雄一日遊
墾丁一日遊
台南一日遊
租車旅遊
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Post a Comment
<< Home